Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star rating

Review score

Oyster Bay – 75 hotels and places to stay
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island, an IHG Hotel, hotel in Oyster Bay

This Holiday Inn boasts an on-site restaurant, free Wi-Fi, and an outdoor pool. Downtown Manhattan is 30 miles away and Walt Whitman Mall is 5.7 miles away from this non-smoking property.

The location is about 30-minute ride from J. F. K. Airport, and the rooms are extremely comfortable and clean. The staff are also quite friendly and helpful. Overall an enjoyable experience!
7.7
Scored 7.7
Good
Rated good
202 reviews
Price fromUS$199.82per night
The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel, hotel in Oyster Bay

Providing elegant all-suite accommodations furnished with fully equipped kitchens, this Woodbury, New York hotel is located on the North Shore of Long Island and is surrounded by local attractions.

clean and bigger rooms, swimming pool not available, they said its half board but when you called the hotel closed on weekend
9.0
Scored 9.0
Superb
Rated superb
301 reviews
Price fromUS$200.93per night
Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown, Ny, hotel in Oyster Bay

Set in Huntington, 26 km from Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum, Hampton Inn & Suites Huntington Downtown, Ny offers air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi and concierge services.

Breakfast OK - some days better than others - all pre-cooked and heavy on carbs.
8.3
Scored 8.3
Very good
Rated very good
129 reviews
Price fromUS$201.56per night
Days Inn by Wyndham Woodbury Long Island, hotel in Oyster Bay

This Long Island hotel is situated near scenic parks and shopping centers and offers comfortable accommodation and many free amenities.

What breakfast? All they had was coffee and granola bars.
7.0
Scored 7.0
Good
Rated good
826 reviews
Price fromUS$120.50per night
Inn At Jericho, hotel in Oyster Bay

Set within 8.9 km of Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum and 18 km of Belmont Park Race Track, Inn At Jericho features rooms with air conditioning and a private bathroom in Jericho.

Clean and feels secure, giod strong bright lights in the car parking
7.6
Scored 7.6
Good
Rated good
409 reviews
Price fromUS$132.84per night
SureStay Plus by Best Western Woodbury Inn, hotel in Oyster Bay

SureStay Plus by Best Western Woodbury Inn, located in Long Island, New York, offers daily free continental breakfast and free WiFi.

Nothing. Stay clear of this place their is a non disclosed "security" deposit not disclosed of 100 Dollars on Booking.com You have to pay this and they tell you you can expect it returned after one week. Two months nearly from my stay and despite emails from me to them I am still awaiting the refund. No issues raised re my stay. NO response acknowledgement from my email.😞😡
6.2
Scored 6.2
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
366 reviews
Price fromUS$139.65per night
Tides Inn at Stehli Beach, hotel in Oyster Bay

Located across from the beach, this Long Island motel boasts an outdoor pool and on-site tennis courts. Free Wi-Fi is also available. Centre Island Beach Village Park is 3 miles away.

The place was better than expected! It's in a great location, too. There are a few small shops to get actual, not mini-mart food. For insurance, visit Ralph's Pizza if ya can. The beach/water is also right across the street within walking distance. The room was also very clean and, unlike most motels, the door didn't have a huge gap at the bottom. There was BOTH a mini frig and microwave. We also paid an extra $5 to get a king so we also got a small kitchen and a full sized frig. The bathroom was also a good size. It's no Ritz hotel, but for $70/night, you can't get better
6.7
Scored 6.7
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
610 reviews
Price fromUS$121.68per night
Comfort Inn Syosset-Long Island, hotel in Oyster Bay

Comfort Inn Syosset – Long Island is located in Nassau County, 14.1 km from Bethpage State Park. Guests can enjoy a complimentary grab-and-go breakfast every morning and WiFi.

Breakfast was very good for a buffet. It was replenished and kept warm with good choices: scrambled eggs, sausage, bacon, breads, juices, good coffee. All facilities seemed very clean. Everyone working there seemd happy and were quick to ask if you needed any help. I would stay here again.
7.5
Scored 7.5
Good
Rated good
290 reviews
Price fromUS$128.90per night
Hyatt Place Garden City, hotel in Oyster Bay

This Garden City, New York hotel features free WiFi access and an indoor swimming pool. The Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum is 5.5 km away.

Great breakfast Great housekeeping
8.3
Scored 8.3
Very good
Rated very good
932 reviews
Price fromUS$233.31per night
Red Roof PLUS Long Island - Garden City, hotel in Oyster Bay

This motel in Westbury is 38.8 km from New York City. It offers free Wi-Fi, free on-site parking and rooms with a flat-screen TV. John F. Kennedy International Airport is 29.4 km away.

The comfort
6.6
Scored 6.6
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
668 reviews
Price fromUS$149.57per night
See all hotels near Oyster Bay
Subscribe to receive premium deals

Prices drop the moment you sign up!