We went down to the coffee bar around 7:30 am and not a soul around much less coffee. Wish they'd have a simple continental breakfast. And the front door was unlocked.

The historic aspect.

Stayed in December 2023

A little too warm in temperature.

Lovely old house! I loved the attic room.

Stayed in December 2023

They obviously think there is a lot of noise because they give you earplugs but in fact it was very quiet and the main issue was too much light from outside through thin curtains. The room was nowhere near the 250 sq ft they suggest even if you include the bathroom. The lighting was poor. They charge a resort fee to cover things like ?wifi and ?parking (much of which is on street and a drunk driver smashed up 4 cars parked outside while we were there). It also covers the pool at the Adrift Hotel which it says is covered but this does not mean enclosed - when we went it was full - it's very small - there were no pool towels and it's exposed to the air which was cold. This fee is iniquitous.

Very friendly welcome. The room was nicely decorated with a comfortable bed. Table and chairs, but that was all there was room for. Nice to have the parlour to sit in and games to borrow, enjoyed the pub food and live music. Good toiletries. Good wifi.

Stayed in October 2023

We were first assigned to room 5 which was so small I couldn’t figure out where we could put our suitcases. The lady at the front desk was wonderful and so accommodating. I just wish breakfast was still served, it wasn’t easy getting into the restaurants due I’m sure to Rod Run weekend.

Room 15 was excellent! Charming, quaint and a nice sized. The beds were very comfortable and we loved the terrace.

Stayed in September 2023

This is a lovely, well renovated historic property with fun details like a pool and shuffleboard table in the parlor and a delightful garden with yard games. The pub bistro was delicious as well. We fully appreciated being able to use the pool and sauna at the sister hotel Adrift, as well as the complementary bikes for the discovery trail along the beach. The rooms were tastefully renovated with comfortable beds and linens, but as it’s a historic property, guests should be aware that the noises from the street and from room neighbors above and to the side are far more noticeable than in a more recent building (but the hotel is certainly aware as housekeeping left pairs of ear plugs on the bedside tables).

Stayed in August 2023

The room was upstairs and there was no elevator, but we knew that ahead of time.

We were able to walk to the antique mall and a nice place to eat.

Stayed in August 2023

The bartender at night could be friendlier, more attentive and kinder to her support staff.

DeeDee at Check-in is fabulous! She made sure that we had a wonderful experience and had access to all of the amenities. The room was lovely and comfortable. The food and beverages were reasonably good.

Stayed in August 2023

Great staff, great location with a quaint little pub/restaurant.

Stayed in June 2023

Nothing

I loved the character of the old hotel. The floors and stairs were uneven, the wood had history the stained glass windows held such charm. The garden was lovely. Pub food was excellent.

Stayed in July 2023

Price

Comfort and the friendly staff

Stayed in July 2023

Don't check in before 4:00. We showed up at 3:45 and they made it clear that they could not help us until 4:00. The stairs are narrow and steep. The rooms are small. It is a really cool building though and overall very comfortable.

The Shelburne is a historic building but the rooms have been upgraded nicely. The bar is beautiful and the staff is friendly and passionate.

Stayed in June 2023

You could hear the stairs to the floor above in the middle of the night which was kind of noisy.

The staff and accommodations were great! Loved the food and drinks at the pub and shuffleboard table. Great location and atmosphere.

Stayed in February 2023

The mattress was a little lopsided. Sloped on both sides.

The staff is great. Each room is unique, in a good way!

Stayed in January 2023

the bathroom needs more space/shelving to store toiletry kits, etc.

very cozy. staff were super nice. great pub with good food and drinks. fireplaces add a nice, warm touch. love a historic property. room was comfortable with decent sized bathroom. bed and bedding very comfortable.

Stayed in January 2023

You made us the best drink I have ever had. It was a great evening with live music. The bathtub was perfect.

Stayed in January 2023

Nothing really except price going up for adding an extra night

Nice bar, comfortable room / bed and great breakfast

Stayed in December 2022

room was tiny

charming, staff was great

Stayed in October 2022

Nothing. Just went at the wrong time and the stay & dinner were quite pricey. It was during the kite festival.

Stayed in August 2022

Proximity to traffic/noise.

Wonderful ambience, staff, facilities.

Stayed in September 2022

Since the nearby convenient restaurant for breakfast is only Thursday to Saturday we would have been very happy with a breakfast buffet, some granola, fresh fruit, maybe a toaster, some bread or bagels and asst of jam, honey and cream cheese. Too much to ask?

Stayed in September 2022

The clawfoot tub was awkward to use. They were replacing shingles on the roof and it was very loud in our room. We could also hear the person next door all through the night, snoring!

We enjoyed the atmosphere of the hotel. The bar and garden were quiet. The bed was very comfortable.

Stayed in April 2022

Live music late at night. Very loud

The style and the cozy

Stayed in November 2021

Nothing, it is a great spot. Wish they served breakfast….

Very clean and well maintained common areas and room. Nice little touches in the room. Gorgeous cozy space. Loved having coffee on the balcony. Cocktails are great and reasonable price. Dinner was nice for a small town.

Stayed in September 2021

The historic feel

Stayed in September 2021