The 3 best hotels in Shelter Island

based on 101 hotel reviews on Booking.com

• Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

  #1 of 3 hotels in Shelter Island

  Last review posted: 7 days ago

  See the property

  • “Peaceful, pampered , lovely.”
  • “Amazing place! Beautiful getaway”
  • “Amazing stay at Seven”
  • See more reviews of Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island
  • • Boutique Hotels

  
• The Pridwin Hotel

  #2 of 3 hotels in Shelter Island

  Last review posted: 17 days ago

  See the property

  • “Lots to enjoy in this historic and picturesque place.”
  • “My siste and I had a lovely end of season trip and the Pridwin was a wonderful choice.”
  • “Loved it. Beautiful, cozy lovely.”
  • See more reviews of The Pridwin Hotel

  
• Rams Head Inn

  #3 of 3 hotels in Shelter Island

  Last review posted: 11 days ago

  See the property

  • “Beautiful location to visit, some issues with price and quality”
  • “Quiet, beautiful, great food, wonderful staff.”
  • “Lovely low key overnight.”
  • Rams Head Inn has been reviewed 6 times. Some users didn't leave a comment, while other reviews are written in Français or English (US).