81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, United States
#2 of 3 hotels in Shelter Island
Guests' ChoiceBased on 56 hotel reviews
8.9Cleanliness
9.5
Comfort
9.6
Location
9.5
Facilities
9.0
Staff
8.8
Value for money
7.8
Free WiFi
10.0
Each review score is between 1-10. To get the overall score that you see, we add up all the review scores we’ve received and divide that total by the number of review scores we’ve received. We are currently testing a weighted review system in Malta and Iceland (excluding hotel and vacation rental chains). For properties in these countries, the more recent the review, the bigger the impact on the total review score calculation. In addition, guests can give separate ‘subscores’ in crucial areas, such as location, cleanliness, staff, comfort, facilities, value for money and free Wi-Fi. Note that guests submit their subscores and their overall scores independently, so there’s no direct link between them.
You can review an Accommodation that you booked through our Platform if you stayed there or if you arrived at the property but didn’t actually stay there. To edit a review you’ve already submitted, please contact our Customer Service team.
We have people and automated systems that specialise in detecting fake reviews submitted to our Platform. If we find any, we delete them and, if necessary, take action against whoever is responsible.
Anyone else who spots something suspicious can always report it to our Customer Service team, so our Fraud team can investigate.
Ideally, we would publish every review we receive, whether positive or negative. However, we won’t display any review that includes or refers to (among other things):
To make sure reviews are relevant, we may only accept reviews that are submitted within 3 months of checking out, and we may stop showing reviews once they’re 36 months old – or if the Accommodation has a change of ownership.
An Accommodation may choose to reply to a review.
When you see multiple reviews, the most recent ones will be at the top, subject to a few other factors (what language a review is in, whether it’s just a rating or contains comments as well, etc.). If you like, you can sort and/or filter them (by time of year, review score, etc.).
We sometimes show external review scores from other well-known travel websites. We make it clear when we’ve done this.
These guidelines and standards aim to keep the content on Booking.com relevant and family-friendly without limiting expression of strong opinions. They are also applicable regardless of the sentiment of the comment.
Contributions should be travel related. The most helpful contributions are detailed and help others make better decisions. Please don’t include personal, political, ethical, or religious commentary. Promotional content will be removed and issues concerning Booking.com’s services should be routed to our Customer Service or Accommodation Service teams.
Contributions should be appropriate for a global audience. Please avoid using profanity or attempts to approximate profanity with creative spelling, in any language. Comments and media that include 'hate speech', discriminatory remarks, threats, sexually explicit remarks, violence, and the promotion of illegal activity are not permitted.
All content should be genuine and unique to the guest. Reviews are most valuable when they are original and unbiased. Your contribution should be yours. Booking.com property partners should not post on behalf of guests or offer incentives in exchange for reviews. Attempts to bring down the rating of a competitor by submitting a negative review will not be tolerated.
Respect the privacy of others. Booking.com will make an effort to obscure email addresses, telephone numbers, website addresses, social media accounts, and similar details.
The opinions expressed in contributions are those of Booking.com customers and properties and not of Booking.com. Booking.com does not accept responsibility or liability for any reviews or responses. Booking.com is a distributor (without any obligation to verify) and not a publisher of these comments and responses.
By default, reviews are sorted based on the date of the review and on additional criteria to display the most relevant reviews, including but not limited to: your language, reviews with text, and non-anonymous reviews. Additional sorting options may be available (by type of traveller, by score, etc.).
This service may contain translations powered by Google. Google disclaims all warranties related to the translations, express or implied, including any warranties of accuracy, reliability, and any implied warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose and non-infringement.
End of dialog content
Showing 1 – 25
Reviewed: 13 May 2024
Sigalit
United StatesIts beautifully renovated. Located in a perfect spot overlooking the bay, lots of trees, amazing sunsets.
Stayed in May 2024
Reviewed: 27 October 2023
Elizabeth
United StatesThe breakfast was prix fixe. It would have been nice to have a la carte choices.
Location was ideal and the room was lovely. It had a view of the water. The outside porch was perfect with a fireplace. The coffee was free.
Stayed in October 2023
Reviewed: 16 October 2023
Mary
United StatesThe bright cafeteria lights Amat the restaurant for dinner. One 1 main problem was the restaurant that I won’t eat dinner at again. Cold, sterile feeeling with unimaginative food.
Stayed in October 2023
Reviewed: 12 September 2023
Sigalit
United StatesOver priced, expensive to get to (ferry), at this price point they should include breakfast.
Beautiful and charming interior design, beautiful views, very relaxing, comfortable rooms.
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 30 August 2023
Carol
United StatesNothing
Pretty. Comforting. Great location
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 29 August 2023
Rebecca
United StatesEverything was great!
Beautifully decorated (gorgeous!), excellent location (waterfront), a lot of attention to detail, nice amenities (pool, kayaks, bikes, ping pong, tennis).
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 19 August 2023
Clifford
United StatesThe Staff is friendly, but many are young people here on work visas so often they could not answer questions. Communication in general was not great.We did not receive the printed summary of weekly activities until shortly before we left. The Wednesday night BBQ while pleasant, did not have labels on dishes and there were not enough servers.
The hotel is well designed, furnished, landscaped and is very clean
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 14 August 2023
Isabelle
United KingdomBreakfast price is too high for what it is. Concierge was not really helpful, after receiving tip he never got back to us with our outstanding requests. We also asked for a baby crib which was confirmed by email but had to wait another hour when we arrived to actually get it.
Very pretty hotel and very clean
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 14 August 2023
Lisa
United StatesNeeded more information about amenities
The entire facility was excellently maintained and service was the key
Stayed in August 2023
Reviewed: 9 August 2023
Beth
United StatesStaff in dining room brought all food and drinks out at once which for the caliber of restaurant/hotel we didn’t enjoy.
Didn’t have breakfast. Location is divine.
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 31 July 2023
Sylvia
United StatesThe sheets on the bed were stiff.
Staff and service wonderful
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 29 July 2023
Wendy
United StatesEverything was PERFECT!
That everything was included! Kayaks, bikes, paddle boards, complementary boat ride, tennis, cornhole, fire pits- awesome pool, bbq picnic, pickle ball!
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 18 July 2023
Carolyn
United StatesDidn’t have a lot of parking.
I was impressed with how the clean the rooms were and overall resort was.. very cute and nice atmosphere. Restaurant was good and had a beautiful violinist playing. I liked that they turned your bed down for the night, put some more clean towels and put out water and glasses for water by the bed, was very nice! They also had a refrigerator stocked with cold drinks and snacks that were free which was an added bonus, don’t get that these days at most resorts. Overall enjoyed our stay and would go back again!
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 16 July 2023
Levan
United Stateslocation was great
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 5 July 2023
Lisa
United StatesThe hotel was gorgeous. The staff was professional and very accomadating. The rooms lovely. Brand new. The view stunning. The grouds and pool and terrace, etc... I got a complimentary breakfast and boat ride (which they dont advertise) and a yoga class. They had music.
Stayed in July 2023
Reviewed: 28 June 2023
Anne
United StatesThe only criticism I had was the checkin and checkout process seemed inordinately slow. The staff while extremely polite, friendly, and professional seemed alittle unsure of the computer systems. The wait staff, again, couldn't have been nicer or more polite, but very green. The ones I encountered were young, teenage and 20 somethings, who clearly didn't have much, if any, restaurant experience. I realize it's not easy to find professional wait staff as seasonal workers for destination vacation properties.
Location is beautiful and charming. The hotel decor is beautiful, tastefully done, so charming, and high quality. My room was simple but very nicely appointed, immaculate, and bed was comfortable. Cocktails, dinner, and breakfast were superior! My dinner entree was really top notch in both flavor and presentation. All staff were very professional and extremely courteous.
Stayed in June 2023
Reviewed: 2 June 2023
Pooja
GermanyArrangement with booking.com - The reservation through Booking.com said breakfast is included but when we arrived the hotel stated change in terms with those bookings. Hotel gave 40 USD credit for each day. Would have been better to know this before hand.
Staff was very customer friendly - going out of their way to serve and make the stay exceptional. Property - It is recently renovated so everything is in top condition Food - Restaurant food is exceptional
Stayed in May 2023
Reviewed: 13 November 2022
Puka
United StatesFire alarm in room had a high pitched noise, water pressure was low and the design of the shower got water all over. It's an old building so you hear a bit in the rooms if your neighbors are noisy. 18$ cocktails at bar. At least they provided ear plugs.
Recently renovated, super clean and modern but takes you back in time. Lots of amenities. Fire places and fire pits everywhere. Loved that they had an Entire game room!! Very cool idea. Staff were all excellent. Beautiful view of water when walking around.
Stayed in November 2022
Reviewed: 18 October 2022
Wallace
United StatesBreakfast and mattress frame. I'm certain for most people the mattress frame is fine, but there were a few times I was laying on the bed face down looking through my phone, and when you get off the bed without sitting upright your tibia will hit the wooden frame. I'm six foot, pretty athletic, not clumsy, and yet both my tibias are bruised :(
Overall property is nice. It's a small island so getting to and from Points of Interest from the Pridwin as as hub is a convenience. We also came across the Chequit hotel, and ended up having a lunch there, so no regrets electing Pridwin. The views from the hotel bar and restaurant are enchanting. FYI the Pridwin is recently acquired under new management. This was my first time, but just an FYI to future guests.
Stayed in October 2022
Reviewed: 28 September 2022
Stacey
United StatesWe enjoyed everything about our stay. There were not many workers so we saw the same few working tirelessly all day and night to ensure that guests were welcomed, taken care of and attended to. The grounds are amazing and the recent renovation was extremely well done and thoughtful- updated while keeping the character and charm. Fireplaces on in and out provided a lovely atmosphere. The pool was sunny and warm even at the end of September and the kayaks, boats and paddle boards were easily available. The setting is ideal and the food is outstanding. Every dish- breakfast (limited but always replenished and delicious) lunch and dinner.. amazing. They even made me special coffee upon request each morning. There were plenty of places to sit, relax, talk, read and just take in the view. I grew up nearby but never ventured to the pridwin. Can’t wait to go back!!
Stayed in September 2022
Reviewed: 27 September 2022
Amy
United StatesLovely hotel, right on the water with a (very) little beach across the street on the water, paddle boards and kayaks, quaint room, amazing breakfast included, s;mores at night, great views and sunsets!
Stayed in August 2022
Reviewed: 4 September 2022
Zeah
United StatesIt was a busy weekend, so took a long time to get food at the restaurant, but very delicious.
Beautiful property and location, most gorgeous views and very nice staff.
Stayed in August 2022
Reviewed: 31 August 2022
Inge
United Statesnothing
the location is phenomenal and the waterside pool is a gem
Stayed in August 2022
Reviewed: 25 August 2022
Elizabeth
United StatesRoom did not have a refrigerator Shower water pressure could have been better.
Beautiful views of the Peconic, glorious pool, tasteful updates and clean, quiet and airy rooms.
Stayed in August 2022
Showing 1 – 25
Johannesburg, South Africa
Boverdalen, Norway
Marmora, USA
Sandiniés, Spain
Sanya, China
Valderas, Spain
Hikkaduwa, Sri Lanka
Split, Croatia
Booking.com is part of Booking Holdings Inc., the world leader in online travel and related services.
We have more than 70 million property reviews, and they're all from real, verified guests.
1
The only way to leave a review is to first make a booking. That's how we know our reviews come from real guests who have stayed at the property.
2
When guests stay at the property they check out how quiet the room is, how friendly the staff are and more.
3
After their trip, guests tell us about their stay. We check for naughty words and verify the authenticity of all guest reviews before adding them to our site.
If you booked through us and want to leave a review, please sign in first.
End of dialog content