The 30 Best Hotels in Long Island

Ranked 1 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 1 for hotels in Port Washington.

• “A do not miss place to stay, THIS HOTEL, and Port Washington.”
• “The Owners made us feel at home and we enjoyed our conversations.”
• “From the extremely comfortable rooms, the warm bagels and croissants that are left outside your bedroom door each mornin”
• See more reviews of Fathoms Hotel & Marina

Ranked 2 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 12 for hotels in Greenport.

• “amenities were fantastic from bar, to hot croissants and...”
• “One of the thing I love most when I stay at a hotel is...”
• “Great stay , clean the best Staff”
• See more reviews of The Menhaden Hotel

Ranked 3 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Wonderful, cosy resort getaway”
• “Highly recommend this place. Ver”
• “It was awesome though its cold and they dont have their own resto it would be perfect if they have it!”
• See more reviews of Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort

Ranked 4 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 3 of 12 for hotels in Greenport.

• “Fantastic service, gorgeous rooms, and the private beach was...”
• “Awesome”
• “It's a very nice hotel.”
• See more reviews of Hotel Moraine

Ranked 5 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 5 for hotels in Amagansett.

• “Delightful accommodations in a lovely town!”
• “Cosy, luxurious and enjoyable stay”
• “Small boutique hotel but so lovely”
• See more reviews of The Roundtree, Amagansett

Ranked 6 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 10 for hotels in Riverhead.

• “The location was perfect for staying near the Hamptons and...”
• “Parking, bathroom and room”
• “Nice hotel but for $400 during the off-season a night not worth the money”
• See more reviews of The Preston House and Hotel

Ranked 7 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 2 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “The rooms were so nice and clean and the pool area very nice.”
• “Love the style and comfort of the room.”
• “Great location, great price. We would definitely come back.”
• See more reviews of Aqualina Inn Montauk

Ranked 8 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 5 for hotels in Garden City.

• “Karen, staff member assisted with carrying my baggage to my car”
• “Very nice hotel. Clean and comfortable!”
• “Fantastic hotel!!!”
• See more reviews of Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

Ranked 9 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Woodbury.

• “Service was excellent”
• “clean and bigger rooms, swimming pool not available, they...”
• “Diuble billed and that sucks”
• See more reviews of The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel

Ranked 10 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 3 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “great hotel very close to a wonderful beach.”
• “The best stay”
• “Great place to stay”
• See more reviews of The Ocean Resort Inn

Ranked 11 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 4 for hotels in Southold.

• “A nice stay”
• “Breakfast was very good and what was expected.”
• “Wonderful !”
• See more reviews of The Shoals Suites & Slips

Ranked 12 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 4 of 12 for hotels in Greenport.

• “Breakfast was good.”
• “I enjoyed our stay a lot.”
• “Great location great staff great food”
• See more reviews of Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows

Ranked 13 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Roslyn.

• “Stay was family related and location facilitated seeing everyone.”
• “The stay was amazing.”
• “The fitness room was clean and well equipped.”
• See more reviews of Hilton Garden Inn Roslyn

Ranked 14 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 4 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Beautiful place with beautiful staff.”
• “Perfect location”
• “Very clean ”
• See more reviews of The Sunset Montauk

Ranked 15 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 2 of 5 for hotels in Amagansett.

• “How can a resort just change your location without your consent”
• “Beautiful but cold”
• “Everything was great.”
• See more reviews of The Hermitage at Napeague

Ranked 16 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 2 of 10 for hotels in Southampton.

• “Nicest motel ever.”
• “We had a pleasant short getaway!”
• “overall, very comfortable, wouldn’t hesitate to book again!”
• See more reviews of The Bentley Hotel Southampton

Ranked 17 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 2 of 8 for hotels in Hampton Bays.

• “Clean and easy”
• “Excellent”
• “Very relaxing”
• See more reviews of Colonial Shores Resort

Ranked 18 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 5 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “pleasant experience”
• “Beautiful architecture, the water view, close to the center...”
• “Beautiful property”
• See more reviews of Montauk Manor

Ranked 19 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Yaphank.

• “I Love everything about this Hotel.”
• “Comfy beds, large spaces with great counter space and blackout blinds for sleeping late in the morning”
• “Very nice. Staff was friendly. Better price too than many accommodations on Long Island yet better quality. I will stay”
• See more reviews of Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven

Ranked 20 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Bridgehampton.

• “Nice place for a night or 2”
• “Adequate”
• “The Matre De was outstanding, Couldn't ask for better...”
• See more reviews of Bridgehampton Inn

Ranked 21 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 1 for hotels in Amagansett.

• “We had a great time.”
• “Mattress a little worn”
• “Paradise so close to home”
• See more reviews of Sea Crest

Ranked 22 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 3 of 8 for hotels in Hampton Bays.

• “Great Stay”
• “We had a lovely stay and would definitely come back again”
• “The owner and staff are very nice and willing to accommodate to make your stay pleasurable”
• See more reviews of Ocean View Terrace

Ranked 23 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 1 for hotels in Quogue.

• “Beautiful hotel”
• “Enjoyable stay!”
• “Very good”
• See more reviews of The Quogue Club

Ranked 24 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 7 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Great Hotel”
• “Magical place in Montauk right next to the beach.”
• “Beautiful location and lovely stay.”
• See more reviews of Marram

Ranked 25 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 8 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Wonderful”
• “The manager is a a sweetheart she is absolutely amazing!”
• “Overall a great experience the staff were very accommodating and thoughtful and let us check out later after telling the”
• See more reviews of Sun and Sound Montauk

Ranked 26 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 9 of 28 for hotels in Montauk.

• “Location, location, Location.”
• “I had a very relaxing stay and loved this oasis at the beach!”
• “Excellent location, room size was perfect for two and the...”
• See more reviews of Montauk Blue Hotel

Ranked 27 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 3 for hotels in Medford.

• “Very clean.”
• “Great stay”
• “Gem of a place”
• See more reviews of 112 Motel

Ranked 28 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 1 of 2 for hotels in Holtsville.

• “Mixed.”
• “Cleanliness”
• “It was okay, I was looking for a more calmer and relaxing stay.”
• See more reviews of Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel

Ranked 29 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 5 of 12 for hotels in Greenport.

• “Nice getaway, funky boutique vibe, excellent restaurant - needs some TLC. Showing signs of wear”
• “Fun night stay”
• “Staff was amazing, and communicated throughout our stay. The restaurant on site had fairly priced food, and was deliciou”
• See more reviews of American Beech Hotel

Ranked 30 out of 162 in the region, as well as being 2 of 3 for hotels in Shelter Island.

• “My siste and I had a lovely end of season trip and the Pridwin was a wonderful choice.”
• “Loved it. Beautiful, cozy lovely.”
• “Beautiful gem in Shelter Island”
• See more reviews of The Pridwin Hotel