The 30 Best Holiday Rentals in New York State

Ranked 1 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Hector.

• “BETTER THAN I EVER COULD HAVE EXPECTED. SEE YOU ON MY NEXT STAY.”
• “Perfect”
• “We stayed last year and loved it. That’s why we came back. We are looking to book again next year.”
• See more reviews of Single Island Shores

Ranked 2 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Coram.

• “Lovely Suite”
• “Absolutely perfect.”
• “The room was exceptionally clean, comfortable and nice.”
• See more reviews of Private Apt King Suite, L.I, NY-Hamptons to NYC

Ranked 3 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 5 for holiday rentals in Roscoe.

• “It was a wonderful stay with great hosts.”
• “It was a great weekend to spend time with the family in a beautiful cottage.”
• “My friend and I really enjoyed our stay. It was the perfect getaway!”
• See more reviews of Roscoe Cottage Pet Friendly

Ranked 4 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 60 for holiday rentals in New York.

• “No complaints only compliments from me.”
• “Everything about Mint House was incredible.”
• “Loved my stay, can’t wait to be back!”
• See more reviews of Mint House at 70 Pine

Ranked 5 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 5 for holiday rentals in Richfield Springs.

• “This stay exceeded our expectations.”
• “Lovely location.”
• “The decor was lovely and homey, and we enjoyed our stay. It's a beautiful place in the fall.”
• See more reviews of Coolis Apartment

Ranked 6 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 36 for holiday rentals in Buffalo.

• “A small house prepared with a lot of love - wonderful stay...”
• “Very nice and inside, and the space is used very well to be...”
• “Awesome, better than expected”
• See more reviews of Cozy Updated 3-BR apartment near Peace Bridge

Ranked 7 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Marathon.

• “We really enjoyed our stay here and will definitely look to again for skiing.”
• “Great location, clean and comfortable. Check in was seamless.”
• “I would visit again”
• See more reviews of Froggy Goggle Barn

Ranked 8 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 5 for holiday rentals in Rhinebeck.

• “We have not found hotels in the area that are very good. This place was a find! We will be staying again.”
• “This is such a great space! Perfect place to stay while in town for a retreat!”
• “Amazing place and great hosts!”
• See more reviews of Private Studio Close to Downtown Rhinebeck

Ranked 9 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 7 for holiday rentals in Corning.

• “Good price for the value”
• “Super bnb”
• “Excellent host, facility, location and value. Highly recommended”
• See more reviews of Little peace of heaven

Ranked 10 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 7 for holiday rentals in Auburn.

• “Fantastic Getaway!”
• “No less than perfect”
• “A very nice place to stay right on the lake.”
• See more reviews of Serenity On The Lake

Ranked 11 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 4 for holiday rentals in Liberty.

• “Fantastic place for a romantic getaway”
• “The location was great for us.”
• “N/A”
• See more reviews of Elegantly English Catskills

Ranked 12 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Cairo.

• “Lovely property that was ideal for our group stay over the...”
• “Home away from home”
• “The house is lovely.”
• See more reviews of Spring Time ! Cozy Getaway Cottage Pet Friendly Place

Ranked 13 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 37 for holiday rentals in Brooklyn.

• “The appartment was absolutely perfect.”
• “A nice place to stay in Brooklyn.”
• “Had a wonderful time, felt super comfortable and would stay here again! 10/10 would reccomend!”
• See more reviews of Vakb Apartments

Ranked 14 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 5 for holiday rentals in Roscoe.

• “Mike and Deb were great!”
• “Everything was wonderful!”
• “It was excellent we had a wonderful weekend and we will definitely stay there again!”
• See more reviews of Roscoe Cabin Pet friendly

Ranked 15 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 9 for holiday rentals in Wilmington.

• “Super close to Whiteface and much better value than stay...”
• “My fiancée says it was “magical””
• “We will definitely come back and stay a little longer!”
• See more reviews of The Wilderness Inn: Chalets

Ranked 16 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 6 for holiday rentals in Alexandria Bay.

• “Fell in love with the place instantly and am already planning a trip back!”
• “Perfect!”
• “Great location! Very clean, updated property”
• See more reviews of The Ledges Resort & Marina

Ranked 17 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 60 for holiday rentals in New York.

• “Very convenient place to visit NY”
• “Good location.”
• “Beautiful fully-equipped art deco appartment in Harlem”
• See more reviews of Spacious Fully Furnished Harlem Apartment Near Morningside Park

Ranked 18 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Ulster Park.

• “Amazing! It fit our needs and made our family getaway so more enjoyable than a hotel stay - it felt like a home away fro”
• “Great place”
• “Loved everything about it”
• See more reviews of Newly Renovated 3BR Hudson Valley House

Ranked 19 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 37 for holiday rentals in Brooklyn.

• “Would recommend for affordable stay in New York.”
• “It is the BEST accommodation I have ever stayed abroad”
• “Great place in Brooklyn”
• See more reviews of Sandy's Place NYC 1

Ranked 20 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 1 for holiday rentals in Nunda.

• “This was our 1st night stay of the trip and all we wanted to do was to come back!”
• “Charming and well equipped cabin”
• “Just gorgeous”
• See more reviews of Letchworth Farm Guesthouses

Ranked 21 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 2 for holiday rentals in Palenville.

• “Heavenly”
• “Relaxing fall getaway!!”
• “Lea was super helpful.”
• See more reviews of Play All Day - Sleep By The Stream at Night - Swimming Hole

Ranked 22 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 3 of 60 for holiday rentals in New York.

• “Perfect apartment for our first time in New York”
• “Location was just perfect.”
• “Perfect rental for two in a great location”
• See more reviews of Fully Furnished Entire Floor Apartment in Historic Harlem

Ranked 23 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 11 for holiday rentals in Kingston.

• “A sensory delight filled with beauty and comfort.”
• “Great place to stay. Would come back again if in area.”
• “Can’t wait to go back!”
• See more reviews of The Stables

Ranked 24 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 4 of 7 for holiday rentals in Saugerties.

• “Had a really wonderful stay here - the house was clean,...”
• “Very nice house.”
• “We had a great 3 day stay! Recommended!”
• See more reviews of Catskill home with King bed, indoor hot tub and BBQ near Woodstock and skiing

Ranked 25 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 4 of 60 for holiday rentals in New York.

• “Better than a normal hotel / possibility to cook...etc...”
• “Loved our stay and lovelyTquanae at reception catered to all our needs.”
• “Fantastic hotel for a group holiday.”
• See more reviews of Placemakr Wall Street

Ranked 26 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 5 of 60 for holiday rentals in New York.

• “Very good flat, best location”
• “This is an excellent place to stay: short or long-term.”
• “Good location and comfortable apt.”
• See more reviews of Sonder City Hall Park

Ranked 27 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 2 for holiday rentals in Livingston Manor.

• “Great time with my friends”
• “Definitely would go back again. The owners were awesome.”
• “We loved it and it was perfect for what we had planned.”
• See more reviews of Cozy and Charming Cottage with Jacuzzi and Fire Pit!

Ranked 28 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 2 of 3 for holiday rentals in Mount Vernon.

• “Great size for a longer stay and close distance to city.”
• “Comfortable, spacious”
• “This apartment is super clean, cozy and inviting.”
• See more reviews of Colorful, Comfy & Modern - Close to NYC - Parking!

Ranked 29 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 4 of 53 for holiday rentals in Rochester.

• “Beautiful old home and a great host”
• “Everything was just perfect!”
• “Peaceful and warm!”
• See more reviews of Seabreeze Three Bedroom Home

Ranked 30 out of 1,249 in the New York State region, as well as being 1 of 8 for holiday rentals in Hunter.

• “Very well designed and equiped property.”
• “Fantastic ski location.”
• “Unbelievable vacation rental for family and dog in the Catskills!”
• See more reviews of SPECTACULAR CATSKILLS 4 BEDROOM VACATION OASIS- Gorgeous Hunter Mountain Views!